Aye, naw, dinae ken, whit?

Campaigning can be fun

This is not a political blog, and although my books have a political background I rarely mention the darker arts here.

But the proximity of the referendum for Scottish independence, and the way it is shaping thinking and lives prompts me to say something about it so others can gain some idea of the transformation taking place.

At the start of the campaign over two years ago, the No side (a coalition of Labour, Conservative, Liberal Democrat and UKIP parties plus some others) had a substantial lead — around twenty per cent. Since then, the Yes side (Scottish National Party, Green, Scottish Socialist Party, Labour for Independence, and a raft of other organisations and groupings) has gradually narrowed that lead, until at present there are only a few points between the sides.

Upturned boats

The Scottish Parliament building, designed by the Spanish architect Enric Miralles, and opened on 9th October 2004

The No campaign (originally calling itself Better Together and using a UKOK logo, but recently relaunched as No Thanks) has been overseen by the UK government (a Conservative/Liberal Democrat coalition), with as its leader a former UK chancellor (now backbencher) from the Labour Party.


Signs like this are being put up in fields by many farmers and landowners.

On the Yes side the campaign is run by a cross-party organisation called Yes Scotland, with input from the Scottish Government and the other parties and organisations favouring independence.


Wooden cutout Yes campaign signs like these are appearing in many gardens.

Two referendums on the governance of Scotland have been held previously.

The UK came about in 1603 when the crowns of the two countries were unified, James VI of Scotland being Elizabeth 1 of England’s nearest heir. Then in 1707, for many and varied reasons, the nobles who sat in the Scottish parliament at the time decided a parliamentary union with the ‘auld enemy’ England would suit their purposes. Rioting took place but the union went ahead.

Over the years a number of attempts were made in the UK parliament to give Scotland home rule, and the Liberal Party for decades embraced home rule for Scotland as one of their key beliefs, though of late it has taken a back seat.

Then in 1979 we were allowed our first referendum, not on independence but on an extremely limited package of devolution of a small number of powers. Because of a 40% rule inserted into the referendum legislation, requiring the proposal to be passed by 40% of those registered to vote (including, since an old election register was in use, those who had died) the referendum result was regarded as being against change although a majority actually voted in favour.

Open democracy

Scottish Parliament new entrance designed to cope better with the large number of people visiting.

The demand for change did not fade away, and eighteen years later, in 1997, a second referendum took place, with a large majority voting in favour of a devolved Scottish parliament with a range of powers including very limited tax raising powers.

Now seventeen years later, because the Scottish National Party (SNP) won an overall majority in the 2011 Scottish parliament election, we are having a referendum on independence.

No shop

No campaign shop in the Scottish Borders

The debate is concerned with democracy, the fact that Scotland rarely gets the government at Westminster that it votes for, with only one Conservative MP in Scotland. The well-worn joke being that there are more pandas (two) here than Conservative MPs.

It is also a debate, not about the past, but about the type of Scotland and society we want to live in and leave to our children and grandchildren. The apathy that has for too long ruled, has been shaken to the core. The people who live in Scotland (including many not born here) have become engaged, eager to have input, make their voices heard on a range of issues.

On the fence but off

Yes poster on a fence

Across all society, dozens and dozens of groups have been set up to campaign from their own perspectives — from academics and creatives, Asians and pensioners, business people and students, film makers and athletes, nuclear disarmers and veterans, young people and mums, farmers and LGBT, Italians and social workers, Africans and Christians, Third sector and EU citizens, fishermen and trade unionists, cabbies and crofters, and groups of those from England, Hong Kong, France, Denmark, Canada, Poland and others, socialists and conservatives, radicals, teachers, NHS Scotland staff and the disabled.

Around the country we’ve seen an explosion of public meetings in halls crammed full, people coming along to hear what’s being said, grabbing the opportunity to ask the questions that burn in their minds. They’ve been bombarded by the media and by leaflets through letterboxes, by street stalls, and declarations to be signed. And from this an alternative media has been born.

Yes again

Yes sticker on a car rear window.

In a profusion of news and political blogs and more personal blogs, on Twitter and Facebook, in books, and plays, and poetry, in concerts, Scottish-wide tours, and in pop-up events of music and everything else thrown in, people in Scotland have come alive, got involved, anxious to campaign.

The date of the referendum is 18th September. Whatever the result on that day, one thing is certain — life and society in Scotland will never be the same again. A spirit, long comatose, has been reawakened, and demands significant change.

And for a taster of the campaign in its final weeks, here are the videos produced by No Thanks and the Yes campaigns. Enjoy.



About jingsandthings

I am me. What do I like? Colour Shapes Textures Paintings, photographs, sculptures, woven tapestries, wonderful materials. The love of materials probably comes from my father who was a textile buyer, and I grew up hearing the names of mills and manufacturers which sounded magical and enticing. Glass in all its soft and vibrant colours and flowing shapes, even sixties glass which makes its own proud statement. A book I can immerse myself in. Meals with family or friends with lots of chat and laughter (and probably a bottle or two of wine). The occasional trip abroad to experience the sights, sounds, food, conversation, quality of light and warmth of other countries. To revel in differences and be amazed by similarities. I like to create and to experience, to try and to achieve. And then there are words – read, heard, written at my keyboard, or scrawled on sticky notes, or along the edges of dog-eared supermarket receipts excavated from the unexplored nooks of my handbag. What do I dislike? Cold Snow Bad design Fast food Condescension
This entry was posted in Events of interest and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Aye, naw, dinae ken, whit?

  1. “Ch-ch-ch-changes, turn and face the strain…” Read about it in the paper here in Tokyo the other day.I believe there are national tendencies in many corners of the world at the moment, here as well. Wish you a peaceful process.

    • It’s all been fairly peaceful to date. But recently a few extremist nutters have tried to stir trouble. An egg was thrown at a politician who is making much of it whilst refusing to report it to the police, causing suspicions to gain credence. One branch of a political party posted arrangements on its FB page for a post vote champaign celebration,and received so much ridicule the event was apparently cancelled. Ridicule and satire have been much used, weapons much more creative and satisfying than resorting to anything stronger.

  2. carol1945 says:

    Living in San Francisco, I actually have heard almost nothing about this issue. I am so, so glad you posted this!!! Thank you for including both the yes and no video ads. I am fascinated and will be quite interested in the outcome.

    • Thanks, Carol. I’m not surprised our referendum hasn’t been widely reported beyond Scottish shores, even people in England, especially London, know little about it. This is very obvious from comments on television and the media. But here discussions and debates have been taking place for nearly three years. In recent decades apathy has been the election winner, but there is talk of turnout in the referendum perhaps reaching 80%. That would be unprecedented. I’ll certainly be posting an update.

  3. carol1945 says:

    Now that the Scotland referendum is on my radar screen, I just read in the New York Times that Wales is thinking of doing something similar if the Yes wins in Scotland.

    • Wales, like Scotland, has an assembly though it has fewer powers than the Scottish Parliament. Wales, historically, is in a slightly different situation from Scotland as it was a Principality annexed by England many centuries ago. Whereas the union of Scotland and England (including Wales) began with the Union of the Crowns when our Scottish king, as the nearest heir to England’s Elizabeth, took over the crown of England as well. Then a century later came the union of the Parliaments. Whereas Scotland retained its own educational and legal systems and church, Wales did not, though it did manage to hang on to its language. There has been less support for Wales to become independent and it is being given more devolved powers. But you never know…once political systems begin to change they can gather speed. Inequality and a lack of democracy can be a strong driving force. Interesting times.

  4. I’m glad to have read your round-up. The noise about it on TV is often too much to wade through! It’s nice to read something so well put together for both sides.

    • I suspect many people here have switched off by now. The unbelievable part of the whole debate is the vast numbers of people registering to vote, people who haven’t voted for years because they were totally disillusioned by the democratic process, and even people who have never voted before. Last night at midnight was the cut off for voter registration, and yesterday in Glasgow there were queues outside the registration office, and many campaigning groups had piles of forms to submit. People have become engaged like never before. But it’s a phenomenon the media aren’t really picking up, or if they are it doesn’t seem to merit a mention. So whatever the outcome, life in Scotland will have a different hue.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.